What New Zealand girls told us
Schools are telling girls to be ambitious, but the culture around them is still teaching them to hide it.
Most girls feel encouraged (72%), yet more than half make themselves seem less ambitious than they are (54%). Encouragement alone isn’t closing the gap.
Seven key findings
Girls feel encouraged to be ambitious, but many still hold themselves back.
72% say their school encourages them, yet 54% make themselves seem less ambitious than they are.
Confidence in girls is read as arrogance, and girls shrink themselves in response.
Ambition girls see as natural in boys gets labelled bossy or arrogant in girls, and girls who see this are four times as likely to downplay their ambition.
Grade pressure is harming girls’ wellbeing in every kind of school.
70% say it affects their wellbeing, at the same rate in co-ed and single-sex schools.
Girls fear failure for what it says about their ability and how they look to others.
Around two-thirds fear they lack talent or worry what others think when they fail.
When schools treat failure as normal, girls doubt their ability less.
Fear of lacking talent falls from 74% to 51% where girls say failure is treated as part of learning.
Single-sex schools do more to make girls’ ambition feel welcome.
86% of single-sex respondents feel they can be ambitious and accepted, against 48% at co-ed schools.
Girls at single-sex schools are twice as confident sharing ideas in class.
73% feel confident sharing ideas, against 35% of girls at co-ed schools.
Percentages are the share of all respondents who agreed or strongly agreed, so neutral answers stay in the total.
Some interesting themes emerged
Some findings reflect familiar patterns about girls and achievement. Others run against common assumptions, and may matter most for how schools respond.
Confident girls pay a likeability penalty.
69% say girls’ confidence is mistaken for arrogance, and 54% make themselves seem less ambitious. Girls describe being called “bossy”, “uptight” or a “teacher’s pet”.
Girls blame setbacks on a lack of talent, not effort.
63% fear they don’t have enough talent when they fail, matching wider research on how girls explain their setbacks.
Academic success still ranks below sport and the arts.
57% say sporting or arts success is celebrated more than academic success; only 19% disagree.
Girls’ achievement is expected, while boys’ is praised.
In their own words, girls describe high achievement as simply expected of them, being told they are good at maths “for a girl”, and being steered away from maths and physics.
Trying hard is not seen as uncool.
73% say caring about academic success is accepted among their peers (5% disagree), and half reject feeling pressure to hide how hard they work. Only 32% feel that pressure.
The pressure comes from within, not from fear of losing friends.
Only 25% think people lose interest in them when they fail, and girls are split on whether failing disappoints important others. The weight is self-doubt and reputation.
Girls see the specific double standard more clearly than the general one.
Only 46% say ambitious girls are viewed differently from ambitious boys, with a third neutral, yet 69% say girls’ confidence is mistaken for arrogance.
Girls don’t see themselves as lacking confidence.
A confidence workshop came last among supports (24%). Girls would rather hear from older students (58%) and talk openly about their experiences (57%).
104 girls at New Zealand secondary schools
Girls aged 15–18 took part in an anonymous, voluntary survey between 29 July and 14 October 2026. Most were in senior years, over half were taking the International Baccalaureate, and almost two-thirds came from migrant families.
Co-ed and single-sex schools
- Co-ed school58%
- Single-sex school42%
Age
- 1512%
- 1623%
- 1736%
- 18 or older30%
International Baccalaureate (IB)
- Currently taking IB55%
- Planning or considering IB5%
- Unsure15%
- Not considering IB25%
Born in New Zealand or overseas
- Born overseas27%
- NZ-born, a parent born overseas37%
- NZ-born, parents NZ-born36%
- Prefer not to say1%
Were you, or either of your parents, born in a different country?
Percentages may not add to 100 because of rounding. School type was added partway through the survey, so it covers about half of respondents; all of them were taking the IB.
Single-sex schools change the climate, not the pressure girls carry
Girls at single-sex schools feel far more backed in their ambition and are more confident sharing ideas in class. But on the pressures girls carry inside, the two groups look much the same.
Co-edSingle-sex
Single-sex schools do more to make girls’ ambition feel welcome
Every girl at a single-sex school said girls there are encouraged to be academically ambitious, against half of girls at co-ed schools. These are large, statistically significant differences, and they hold after allowing for age.
Girls are encouraged to be ambitious
I can be ambitious and accepted at my school
My school supports intellectual risk-taking
Girls at single-sex schools are twice as confident sharing ideas in class
Nearly three-quarters of girls at single-sex schools feel confident sharing their ideas in class, against about a third at co-ed schools.
I feel confident sharing my ideas in class
I avoid speaking even when I have something to say
The confidence gap is statistically significant when tested on its own and after allowing for age. The speaking-up gap while large is not statistically significant. This is a potential area for further research.
But the pressures girls carry look much the same
Grade pressure affects my wellbeing
Afraid I lack talent when failing
I seem less ambitious than I really am
Confidence in girls mistaken for arrogance
Even at single-sex schools, where every girl said they were encouraged, nearly two-thirds still make themselves seem less ambitious than they are. Single-sex schooling appears to change the environment and girls’ voice in class, but not the pressures girls carry inside.
School type was asked of respondents to the later survey version, all IB students. The school-climate differences in finding 6 are statistically significant and hold after allowing for age; the differences in this chart are not. Each group likely comes from a small number of schools, so school type cannot be fully separated from individual school culture.
Findings by theme
Every survey question maps to one of the six constructs described on The Project page. Quotes are taken from students’ written responses to the survey questions.
AgreeNeutralDisagree
Academic confidence and participation
Only half feel confident sharing ideas in class, and almost as many stay quiet when they have something to say. 48% don’t feel confident choosing challenging subjects.
I feel confident sharing my ideas in class
50% agree
27% neutral · 23% disagree
I sometimes avoid speaking even when I have something to say
46% agree
25% neutral · 29% disagree
I feel confident choosing academically challenging subjects
52% agree
33% neutral · 15% disagree
“If girls are being hesitant to add their input in class, forcing them to answer… won’t help.”
Downplaying or hiding success
Over half make themselves seem less ambitious, and feeling encouraged makes no difference to whether they do. But most don’t feel they must hide how hard they work.
I make myself seem less ambitious or confident than I really am
54% agree
22% neutral · 24% disagree
I downplay my academic success around my friends
48% agree
34% neutral · 18% disagree
I feel pressure to hide how hard I work to fit in
32% agree
18% neutral · 50% disagree
“We down-play our success because we think it’ll make others feel bad, but we do really want to do well.”
Fear of failure and perfectionism
Girls fear failure for what it says about their ability and how they look to others, not because they’ll lose friends. Where schools treat failure as normal, fear of lacking talent falls from 74% to 51%. Measured with the PFAI-S.
When failing, it upsets my plan for the future
66% agree
12% neutral · 22% disagree
When failing, I fear I might not have enough talent
63% agree
17% neutral · 19% disagree
When failing, I worry what others think of me
63% agree
14% neutral · 22% disagree
When failing, people are less interested in me
25% agree
24% neutral · 51% disagree
“Sometimes it’s less scary to not try than it is to try and fail.”
School culture and peer norms
Caring about grades is socially accepted, but academic success is still celebrated less than sport and the arts, and grade pressure is harming girls’ wellbeing in every kind of school.
At my school, girls are encouraged to be ambitious
72% agree
20% neutral · 8% disagree
Among my peers, caring about academic success is accepted
73% agree
22% neutral · 5% disagree
Sport or arts success is celebrated more than academic success
57% agree
24% neutral · 19% disagree
Pressure for high grades affects my wellbeing
70% agree
15% neutral · 14% disagree
“Making it normal to be proud of your achievements and share your successes as well as your failure.”
Gender, identity and belonging
Confidence in girls is read as arrogance, and girls shrink themselves in response: those who see this are four times as likely to downplay their ambition.
The double standard: in their own written comments, girls described the same ambition being judged differently by gender. In boys, ambition is “seen as natural”, “praised” or “celebrated”. In girls, it gets labelled “bossy”, “cocky”, “uptight”, a “know-it-all” or a “teacher’s pet”.
Confidence in girls is sometimes mistaken for arrogance
69% agree
18% neutral · 12% disagree
Ambitious girls are viewed differently from ambitious boys
46% agree
33% neutral · 21% disagree
“Girls face intense pressure to be likeable and modest, whereas male ambition is seen as natural.”
Girls ask for support from each other, not to be fixed
Girls chose peer-led and practical support first. A confidence workshop came last, suggesting girls see the problem in their environment rather than in themselves. Share of girls who answered; they could choose several.
Hearing from older students about the IB58%
Open conversations about girls’ academic experiences57%
A senior-student mentor48%
A workshop on subject choice and managing pressure38%
A written IB transition guide36%
A peer support group25%
A workshop on confidence and academic identity24%
What happens next
Interviews
One-to-one interviews with girls at co-ed and single-sex schools, to understand why they hold back and what would help.
School Toolbox
Eight practical areas where schools can close the gap between encouraging girls’ ambition and girls feeling safe to show it.
Pilots
Peer mentoring and an IB transition guide, run through the CAS programme.
Downloads
Take the findings to your staff room or share them with your school.
About the method
Anonymous, voluntary survey; any question could be skipped. Statements were rated from 1 (strongly disagree) to 5 (strongly agree); fear of failure used the PFAI-S on a 0–100 scale, with 75 or 100 counted as agreeing. Results are reported in aggregate, and quotes are anonymised.
Girls chose to take part, so results describe this group, not every New Zealand student. With about 100 respondents, percentages carry a margin of roughly ±10 points, and links between answers show associations, not cause and effect.
Hear about the next phase
Leave your email and we’ll tell you when the interview findings and toolbox updates are published. Nothing else, no spam.